Assessivo

Type A vs Type B personality: what the science really says

Driven and impatient, or relaxed and easygoing? Where the labels came from, what 60 years of studies found, and what psychologists measure instead.

In short: Type A describes people who are driven, impatient and competitive; Type B describes people who are relaxed and easygoing. The idea came from two heart doctors in the 1950s, but the large studies that followed found no link between Type A and heart disease. Only anger and hostility showed a small link, and much of the early research was paid for by tobacco companies. People also aren't two types: everyone sits somewhere on a scale. Psychologists now measure the traits behind "Type A" one by one, with the Big Five.

Myth or fact? Test yourself first3 quick statements

Type A people are more likely to have heart attacks.

Frequent anger is linked with heart disease.

Most people are clearly Type A or Type B.

What is a Type A personality?

"Type A" is shorthand for a pattern of behaviour: always in a hurry, ambitious, competitive and easily irritated when things are slow. It isn't a diagnosis or an official personality type. It describes one end of a scale that everyone sits somewhere on.

What is a Type B personality?

Type B is the other end of the same scale: patient, unhurried and hard to rattle. It was first defined simply as "not Type A", which is why it gets less attention, even though more people search for it.

Common Type A traits
  • Time urgency: walks, talks and eats fast; hates queues.
  • Ambition and competitiveness: high goals, keeps score, even in games.
  • Doing several things at once: answers emails during calls.
  • Impatience: annoyed when others are slow.
  • Hard to switch off: feels guilty resting.
Common Type B traits
  • Relaxed about time: deadlines matter, but don't cause panic.
  • Less driven by winning: enjoys the game more than the score.
  • Slow to anger: stays calm when plans change.
  • Reflective: takes time to think things through.
  • Rests without guilt.

Is Type B lazy? No. Type B describes pace and temper, not effort or ability. A Type B person can be just as organised and successful as a Type A person; they simply get there with less hurry.

Type A, B, C and D personality compared

Two more letters were added later. Here is how each label is usually described, and how well the research supports it.

LabelDescribed asHealth claimEvidenceBig Five match
Type ADriven, hurried, competitive, quick to angerHeart diseaseDidn't hold upHigh achievement-striving and activity, lower agreeableness
Type BRelaxed, patient, easygoingProtectiveDidn't hold upThe reverse of Type A
Type CCooperative, eager to please, holds back emotionsCancerDiscreditedNo clear match
Type DWorried, gloomy, socially inhibitedWorse outcomes in heart patientsSome, smaller than claimedHigh neuroticism, low extraversion

Big Five matches from Ramanaiah and others (1997) and Denollet (2005). Sources are listed at the end of the page.

Where the idea came from

Type A was named by two cardiologists, Meyer Friedman and Ray Rosenman, not by psychologists. As Friedman told it, the chairs in their San Francisco waiting room wore out unusually fast, and an upholsterer remarked that their patients must be very restless. They described the behaviour pattern in 1959.

Then came the big studies. In 1975, a study of 3,154 men followed for 8.5 years found Type A "strongly related" to heart disease. The studies that followed were larger, and none of them found the link.

The heart studies: how many people, and what they found

Found a linkFound no linkCircle area = people studied

Seven reality checks about Type A and Type B

Each check sets a popular belief against what the studies found, with the numbers behind it.

1Didn't hold up

"Type A gives you heart attacks"

In the largest test, the MRFIT study, 12,772 men filled in a Type A questionnaire. If Type A raised the risk, the bars below would climb from left to right. They don't. Across every long-term study up to 1998, covering 74,326 people, the link between Type A and heart disease was r = 0.003: effectively zero. Blood pressure, cholesterol and smoking predicted heart disease; Type A didn't.

Men who had a first major heart event, by Type A score

Each bar is one fifth of the men, ranked by their Type A score (crude risk). Shekelle and others, 1985.

Sources: Shekelle and others, 1985; Ragland and Brand, 1988; Myrtek, 2001.

2Surprise

The twist nobody mentions

Among 231 men who survived a first heart attack, the Type A men were less likely to die of heart disease over the following 12 or so years than the Type B men. After adjusting for other risks, their rate was 42% lower. The researchers called it "surprising".

Heart-disease deaths per 1,000 person-years, after a first heart attack

Source: Ragland and Brand, 1988, New England Journal of Medicine.

3Context

Who paid for the research

A personality cause of heart disease was useful to an industry being blamed for it. Tobacco company documents show that the industry was a major funder of Type A research for about 40 years, and that most of the positive findings came from studies or researchers with tobacco funding. Philip Morris called one of its projects its "crown jewel".

Philip Morris funding for Type A research (US dollars)

Meyer Friedman Institute, up to 1997
nearly $11M
A Duke University researcher, 1985 to 1989
$5M

Source: Petticrew, Lee and McKee, 2012, American Journal of Public Health.

4Partly true

Ambition isn't the risky part. Anger might be.

Split Type A into its pieces and only one shows a link: anger and hostility. Across 25 studies of healthy people, it went with a 19% higher risk of heart disease. Being driven or busy did not. Even this link is small, and one large review called it too small to have "practical meaning" for prediction.

Risk of heart disease, compared with people low in the trait

Whole Type A pattern
No link
Anger and hostility: 1.19×

Sources: Chida and Steptoe, 2009; Myrtek, 2001.

5Didn't hold up

"You're either Type A or Type B"

Two studies with more than 4,600 people repeated the key 1989 test that seemed to show two separate groups. They found one smooth scale instead, and concluded there is "no evidence for the type" in Type A. A review of 177 papers found the same for normal personality in general: traits are scales, not boxes.

If there were typesTwo humps, a gap between
What the data showOne hill, no gap

Illustrations of the two possible results, not plotted data.

Sources: Wilmot and others, 2019; Haslam and others, 2012.

6Didn't hold up

"Type C personality causes cancer"

King's College London reviewed the studies by Hans Eysenck and Ronald Grossarth-Maticek on personality and physical health, which were the best-known support for a "cancer-prone personality". It judged them "unsafe" and asked journals to retract them. In a newer study of 42,843 people, none of the Big Five traits predicted getting or dying of cancer.

Big Five traits linked to cancer risk, in 42,843 people

Also no link with cancer deaths, among the 21,835 people with that data.

Sources: King's College London, 2019; Jokela and others, 2014.

7Didn't hold up

"Your type is fixed for life"

Genes explain part of personality, but not most of it. And across 207 studies, therapy and similar programmes measurably changed personality trait scores within about 24 weeks on average; emotional stability changed most. Personality is stable, not set in stone.

Where differences in personality come from

Average across studies with more than 100,000 people.

Sources: Vukasović and Bratko, 2015; Roberts and others, 2017. More in our guide to whether personality is genetic.

The traits are real. The box isn't.

Being driven, fast-paced or quick to anger are real, measurable traits. They just don't come bundled into two types, and only one of them, hostility, has even a small health link.

What is a Type C personality?

Discredited

Type C describes someone cooperative, patient and eager to please, who keeps emotions, especially anger, to themselves. It isn't a mix of Type A and Type B; it was proposed separately, as a "cancer-prone personality".

Is Type C real? The traits exist, but the cancer claim doesn't stand (reality check 6). At work and in relationships, a Type C person as described is easy to work with and caring, but may avoid conflict and leave their own needs unspoken.

What is a Type D personality?

Some evidence

The D stands for "distressed". Psychologist Johan Denollet defined it as two traits together, measured with a 14-question scale called the DS14:

Negative affectivity

worry, gloom and irritability

Close to high neuroticism (r = 0.68)
Social inhibition

holding back with other people

Close to low extraversion

In heart patients, Type D went with worse outcomes, but the effect shrank as studies improved, and there was no link in patients with heart failure.

Link between Type D and worse outcomes in heart patients (odds ratio)

Early studies
5.02
Later studies
1.54

An odds ratio of 1.0 would mean no link. Grande, Romppel and Barth, 2012.

Self-check: where do you sit on the scale?

There's no official Type A test, and a quiz that hands you a letter can't place you on a scale. Answer these five questions instead and see where you lean on each trait. It's a reflection, not a test, and nothing is saved.

Do you get irritated in queues or slow traffic?Impatience

Do you do two things at once to save time?Pace

Do you need to win, even at a casual game?Competitiveness

Do you feel guilty when you rest?Drive

Do small delays make you angry?Hostility

Your answers on the scale

Impatience
Pace
Competitiveness
Drive
Hostility
More Type BMore Type A

Answer all five to see your pattern.

Can you be both Type A and Type B? Yes, and most people are. Because Type A is a scale, you can be ambitious at work but relaxed at home, or fast-paced but slow to anger. Feeling "a bit of both" is exactly what the research predicts.

What to measure instead: the four traits inside "Type A"

Researchers recommend replacing the Type A label with separate trait scales. The traits it bundles together are all part of the Big Five, and our free Big Five personality test scores each of them.

"Type A"one label
  • Achievement-strivingDrive to reach goals · ConscientiousnessNo health link
  • Activity levelPace of life · ExtraversionNo health link
  • AngerHow quickly you get irritated · NeuroticismSmall heart link
  • Cooperation (low)Readiness to argue · AgreeablenessRelated to hostility

Health links from Myrtek (2001) and Chida and Steptoe (2009).

See where you really sit120 statements, about 10 minutes: your scores on all 30 Big Five facets, including the four behind "Type A".
Take the free Big Five test

Type A and Type B at work and in relationships

No job "fits a type", and we found no study showing that Type A and Type B people are more or less compatible. What matters is how the separate traits play out.

SituationStrengthWatch out for
More Type A at workDeadlines, high standards, driveOverwork, friction with colleagues
More Type B at workCalm, careful, long-term workLeaving things late
In relationshipsDifferent paces can balance each otherHow disagreements are handled matters more than the letters
With childrenNotice the separate traitsAvoid labels: children's traits are still developing

Nurses, students and managers often ask which type suits their role. The same split applies everywhere: ambition and pace can help, constant hostility doesn't. If you're choosing a direction, our free career test matches your interests to real jobs, and our guide on how to choose a career walks through the decision.

Type A vs OCD, ADHD and "Type B personality disorder"

Type A and Type B are everyday descriptions, not health conditions. They often get mixed up with three different things.

Often confused

Type A isn't OCD

Obsessive-compulsive disorder is a mental health condition with unwanted, recurring thoughts and repeated behaviours that are hard to stop. Liking order or high standards is not OCD.

Source: NIMH

Often confused

Type A or B isn't ADHD

ADHD is a diagnosed condition that affects attention, activity and impulse control. Being relaxed or restless is not a sign of it, and there's no single test for it: a professional evaluation is needed.

Source: CDC

Doesn't exist

"Type B disorder"

People usually mean Cluster B personality disorders (antisocial, borderline, histrionic and narcissistic), a medical grouping that has nothing to do with Type B.

Source: MSD Manual

If you're worried about any of these, speak to a doctor or psychologist.

Frequently asked questions

Is Type A personality real?

The traits are real, but the type isn't. Being hurried, competitive or quick to anger are real, measurable traits. But studies of more than 4,600 people found one smooth scale from more Type B to more Type A, not two separate groups, and the large heart studies found no link between Type A and heart disease.

Is Type B personality bad or lazy?

No. Type B describes pace and temper, not effort or ability. A Type B person can be just as organised, hard-working and successful as a Type A person; they simply work with less hurry and are slower to anger.

Is there a real Type A test?

Researchers used questionnaires such as the Jenkins Activity Survey and structured interviews, but there is no official Type A test, and online quizzes that give you a letter are not validated. A Big Five personality test is a better option: it scores the separate traits behind Type A, such as achievement-striving, activity level and anger, on scales.

Is Type A personality genetic?

Partly. A meta-analysis of studies with more than 100,000 people found that about 40% of the differences in personality traits between people are linked to genes and about 60% to environment and experience.

Can you change your personality type?

Traits can change. Across 207 studies, therapy and similar programmes changed personality trait scores within about 24 weeks on average, most of all emotional stability. People also tend to become calmer and more conscientious with age.

Is Type A personality linked to anxiety?

Type A is not an anxiety disorder. The part of it closest to anxiety is worry and irritability, which the Big Five measures under neuroticism; Type D, not Type A, is the label built around worry. If worry is affecting your daily life, speak to a doctor or psychologist.

What does the D in Type D stand for?

Distressed. Psychologist Johan Denollet defined Type D as a combination of negative affectivity (worry, gloom and irritability) and social inhibition (holding back with other people), measured with a 14-question scale called the DS14.

Is Type A the same as OCD?

No. Obsessive-compulsive disorder is a mental health condition with unwanted, recurring thoughts and repeated behaviours that are hard to stop. Liking order, working fast or having high standards is not OCD.

How does Type A relate to MBTI or the enneagram?

They are separate systems: Type A and B is not one of MBTI's 16 types or an enneagram type. Like Type A and B, MBTI sorts people into categories, while researchers prefer the Big Five because it measures traits on scales.

Which is better, Type A or Type B?

Neither. A more Type A style often helps with deadlines and goals, and a more Type B style with calm, careful work. The one part with a health link is frequent anger and hostility, and even that link is small.

Are Type A and Type B compatible?

We found no study showing that Type A and Type B people are more or less compatible. Differences in pace can cause friction, but how a couple handles disagreements matters more than the letters.

What is a Type C personality?

Type C describes someone cooperative, patient and eager to please, who keeps emotions, especially anger, to themselves. It was promoted as a cancer-prone personality, but the best-known studies behind that claim were judged unsafe, and a study of 42,843 people found no personality trait that predicted cancer.

How Type A compares with 16-type tests: see Big Five vs MBTI.

Sources

This guide is general information, not medical advice.

Get your real profile, not a letter

See your scores on the five big traits and all 30 facets, including the four behind "Type A". Free, no sign-up.

Take the free Big Five test